Here’s a universal health care situation summary from State Committeewoman Cynthia Stead from the Cape. She’s nailed several key issues. Why don’t protestors from the Tea Party get the same free speech rights as Obamacare supporters from the unions? And why aren’t the people who are pitching this plan addressing crucial and fundamental issues like tort reform?
The Sunday “talking heads” had ceased talking and were nodding sagely. Evil Rush Limbaugh was having a sound bite played on Meet the Press, saying that Speaker Pelosi had a lot more in common with Hitler than people protesting at town hall health care rallies.
Obviously, he and his storm troops had gone around the bend and could be disregarded. Of course, they omitted the sound bite of Madam Speaker saying that the town hall protesters were brown-shirt Nazis carrying swastikas to the meetings — which is what prompted his remarks in the first place.
Last August, Speaker Pelosi was chiding the Chinese for not allowing sufficient dissent and free speech at the Olympic Games. This August, Speaker Pelosi is referring to domestic dissent and free speech as “un-American,” as she is “sure that our health plan can stand up to any questions,” just as long as they come from the Service Employees International Union. These Tea Party people aren’t real community, like ACORN or Democracy for America, who send out e-mails to attend town halls to support the president. These people cannot be genuine, or they’d agree with us.
The debate about national health insurance (we have health care, this is determining the insurance mechanism) has gotten ugly quick, as congressional Democrats seem unable to believe that the nation isn’t dying to have a European-style national health plan, or at least a government single-payer option.
The popularity of single payer has been liberal-received wisdom for so long that the idea that they might have to sell the unread 1,000-page bill is disconcerting to them. Many Massachusetts congressional representatives are holding “town hall” meetings, although there doesn’t seem to be any plans by U.S. Rep. William Delahunt to hold one. Doubtless he is still trying to recover from the trauma of the protests at his office by Cape Codders for Peace & Justice and Peter White, a local activist.
Congressional Democrats at these town hall meetings have been very top-down. For instance, in Georgia, Rep. David Scott had a meeting on a road project, and after the presentation opened the floor to general questions. A doctor stood up and asked questions about the health care bill. Scott blew up, ranting about his real constituents and these imported hijackers interrupting his meeting. The doctor was a constituent, who had been unable to get the congressman’s staff to respond to the questions he had, and so came to the meeting to ask. No apology was offered.
If we did have a town hall here, I’d ask two questions: First, much of the expense of medical care comes from “belt and suspenders” testing by doctors, who fear malpractice suits and awards, and practice defensive medicine. Every television commercial for sleazy lawyers offering cash incentives for people who have taken a medication or been exposed to a danger underscores how real the problem is.
But I haven’t heard anything about tort reform. Will lawyers be able to sue those on a government plan? Or will they only be able to sue those remaining on a plan with a commercial insurer? And hundreds of thousands of people work in the health insurance industry — mostly women, mostly moderate clerical salaries. They log claims, make disbursements, and so on. We moved heaven and earth to save the jobs of the United Auto Workers in Detroit — why are these health insurance workers of no concern? Or will they all just get government jobs?