Gov Patrick Continues to Show Us He Knows How To Live Well…Off Our Tax Dollars
It is extremely unclear whether government hob-nobbing does any good for the business community. Rather than send Gov Patrick and his crew to China, we should send a contingent funded by the manufacturing community to make the outreach. At least Jack Healy from the Worcester MassMEP, the Associated Industries of Massachusetts, and manufacturers like Nypro know what, if anything, they need from the Chinese labor pool.
Instead, we get Gov Patrick spending inordinate amounts of money on over-the-top accomodations. This from the Lawrence Eagle-Tribune:
They traveled more than 15,000 miles to stay at the luxurious Grand Hyatt Beijing and St. Regis Shanghai, and enjoy cocktails, spring rolls and pork dumplings at the private China Club Beijing — where the “privileged few … step back in time to experience what China was like during the Qing Dynasty.”
The self-described delights of the China Club (“fit for an emperor”) and the sights of Beijing and Shanghai were incidental to the stated purpose of the trip to China by a delegation led by Gov. Deval Patrick.
The goal was to promote Bay State clean-energy companies and secure a coveted agreement for direct flights between Beijing and Boston, state officials say.
But the trip last December and Patrick’s plans to travel to Israel and India are raising questions about the value of the international trips that officials call trade missions but critics call junkets.
Trade missions were all but eliminated under Patrick’s predecessor, Gov. Mitt Romney, but are back on the agenda under Patrick.
The China trip cost a total of just over $312,000, with taxpayers paying $236,000 of that.
Expenses included $107,000 in airfare, $58,000 in hotel bills and $53,575 for “hospitality” and receptions, including $14,240 for the China Club shindig.
A $3,050 video crew documented the visit for posterity.
Patrick will travel to Israel in September to talk up the state’s biotech industry and its new $1 billion life sciences initiative. And in 2009, he plans to visit India, bringing high-ranking officials and business executives with him.
The trade missions are part of Patrick’s ambitious agenda to drum up business for Massachusetts.
But the value of these missions is hard to quantify, and state export data suggests they have had little impact on trade in the past.
Critics contend the trips are a waste of taxpayer dollars and are better left to private businesses.
“Most trade occurs between private entities,” said Steven Poftak, research director with the Pioneer Institute, a conservative think tank based in Boston. “These trips typically culminate in government-to-government contacts that don’t necessarily translate into revenue for private industry.”
MassGOP Executive Director Rob Willington said, “Taxpayer funded junkets like these are inexcusable when the people of Massachusetts are being crushed by skyrocketing property taxes and gas prices. Instead of spending $236,000 of our money on lavish trips, Governor Patrick should explain why he hasn’t delivered the property tax relief that Candidate Patrick promised.”